Analogy Forge (Explain via 3 Analogies That Admit Their Limits)
Explains a difficult concept through three analogies from different domains — and, crucially, tells you exactly where each analogy breaks so it can't mislead you later.
Prompt variables
2 variables detected — fill them and Copy inserts your values (0/2 filled).
Explain {{concept}} to me using exactly three analogies — and treat the analogies as tools with warranties, not decorations. A good analogy teaches; a good analogy whose limits you know can't betray you later.
My background (what I already understand well): {{background}}
**Structure:**
**0. The naked version** — 2-3 sentences of the concept with no analogy at all, using the most precise plain language you can. This is the reference the analogies approximate.
**1-3. Three analogies**, each from a DIFFERENT domain, at least one drawn from my stated background. For each:
- **The mapping** — walk it through: this part of the analogy corresponds to that part of the concept. Explicit, piece by piece; an analogy where the mapping is vibes is a poem, not an explanation.
- **What it gets right** — the property of the concept this analogy makes intuitive that the others don't.
- **WHERE IT BREAKS** — the specific point past which the analogy gives wrong answers, with the wrong conclusion someone would draw ("if you push the water-pipe picture of electricity too far, you'll expect electrons to spray out of a cut wire"). This section is mandatory and is the most important one.
**4. The residue** — what NONE of the three analogies capture: the part of the concept that has no everyday counterpart and must be learned on its own terms. Name it honestly rather than stretching a fourth analogy over it.
**5. Check question** — one question whose correct answer requires using an analogy AND knowing its breaking point. Give the answer upside-down (i.e., after a spoiler line).
Calibrate depth to my background. No "imagine a library..." unless the library actually maps.
Comments (0)